Red Shoe Island Bistro

Delicious from start to finish. I've never liked scallops but these deviled eggs with seared scallops were so good. Must try. The fish specials were great, again coming from a guy that prefers red meat and chicken. I think the key lime pie here with a perfectly buttery crust was my favorite of the many I ate all week in KW! Theo provided excellent service.

Must try!! This was our first time at Red Shoe and we will definitely be back. The food was excellent, the service was excellent. Nothing but good things to say. Got the scallop deviled eggs as an app and they were delicious, sounds weird but somehow it works! For dinner we had seafood medley, snapper, and scallops which were all delicious. Dessert we had lavender cheesecake. Also had a bottle of wine which I feel like the wine was reasonably priced! FYI - as space is smaller reservations are best bet (there is some bar seating though). And they don’t serve liquor, beer & wine only!

Highly recommend, great service, amazing food, great atmosphere. I had the yellowtail and entire meal was to die for. If you are in key west, enjoy fresh fish, you will not go wrong. As a heads up, you probably want a reservation, we arrived without one right at opening (6pm) and got a table. 5 min later entire restaurant was filled. As good as this experience was, I expect you will eat somewhere else if you show up without a reservation.